The Dutch Is a Polished Bet for Steak, Drinks and Brunch
Public reviews point to an intimate Soho dining room where crisp fries, well-cooked steak and a standout strawberry doughnut lead the order.
More photos
Photos published by diners on Google, not AI generated.
What stands out
- Perfectly cooked steak
- Crisp, well-seasoned fries
- Fresh strawberry doughnut
- Dim, intimate atmosphere
- Prompt, attentive service
Worth knowing
- Burger may feel unremarkable
- Turkey sandwich drew a disappointed return visit
- Expensive pricing
Suggested meals
Dishes that come up most in public reviews
- Steak with crisp fries
- Hanger steak with kimchi fried rice
- Fresh strawberry doughnut
Worth a visit?
The read on The Dutch
The Dutch presents itself as a polished American restaurant with a serious bar and a brunch menu that attracts nearly as much attention as dinner. Its Google rating of 4.3 from 2456 reviews supports that broad appeal. In the supplied public feedback, diners repeatedly praise the service, atmosphere and execution of familiar dishes, even when individual menu items do not quite meet expectations.
This is an expensive restaurant, and the strongest reports tend to focus on complete experiences rather than novelty alone: prompt seating, attentive waitstaff, well-made drinks and food arriving without a long delay. An early Monday dinner was described as uncrowded and efficient, while another diner arrived before a reservation and comfortably waited at the bar.
What appears to work best
Steak is the clearest dinner recommendation. One reviewer found it perfectly cooked, accompanied by crisp, well-seasoned fries. Another singled out the hanger steak with kimchi fried rice, again noting the fries for their crisp texture. Taken together, those reports make the steak, fries and fried rice combination the safest savory direction in this sample.
The starters and lighter plates also earn specific praise. Carpaccio was called delicious and well balanced, watermelon salad stood out for ripe fruit and a generous serving, and beets with labneh received an emphatic recommendation. Drinks appear dependable too, including a refreshing cucumber and lemon option whose exact menu name was not recalled.
Brunch has one especially consistent draw: the fresh strawberry doughnut. It was the favorite item in one brunch review and described as fantastic in another. That recurrence gives it more weight than the usual one-off dessert endorsement.
Room, bar and service
The atmosphere trends dim, intimate and romantic. That makes The Dutch a natural fit for a date, but the bar also seems comfortable for a solo meal or late lunch. Reviewers mention prompt seating, quick attention from servers and food arriving at a good pace. One report characterized food, drinks and service as excellent across the board.
The bar deserves consideration beyond pre-dinner cocktails. A late-lunch customer was able to share a sandwich and salad there, while another party found seats before its reservation. The overall picture is lively and stylish without every visit feeling crowded, though timing likely plays a role.
Where expectations need managing
Not every familiar American staple lands as a standout. One diner considered the burger high quality but otherwise unremarkable. A returning customer’s companion remembered the turkey sandwich as exceptional from an earlier visit, then found the newer experience hugely disappointing; the reviewer personally judged it merely fine. Those comments suggest that sandwiches and the burger may offer less value than the better-reviewed steak plates, salads and brunch pastry.
The synthesized verdict is favorable but selective. The Dutch looks strongest when treated as an expensive, atmosphere-forward restaurant for steak, crisp fries, drinks and the strawberry doughnut. Diners primarily chasing an extraordinary burger or turkey sandwich may leave less convinced.
Keep exploring near New York
More from NY
NY · New York · $
Fillmore Deli & Backroom Has Range Beyond Sandwiches
A playful daytime deli and nighttime hangout where breakfast burritos, fried chicken and an extensive sandwich menu drive the appeal.
NY · New York · $$
All’Antico Vinaio Brings Big Italian Sandwiches to New York
Crisp, airy bread and generously filled sandwiches make this compact, mid-range counter spot a strong choice for sharing.
NY · New York · $
Joey Roses Makes a Strong Case for the Classic NYC Sub
Fresh bread, filling subs and warm bar service drive the enthusiastic public feedback for this budget-friendly Lower East Side sandwich shop.
NY · New York · $
Russ & Daughters remains a smoked-fish destination
The Lower East Side institution earns its reputation through excellent smoked salmon, broad cream cheese choices and classic bagel sandwiches.
Research-based review: our NY editor synthesized 2456 public reviews and the current 4.3-star rating, not an anonymous visit.