Fillmore Deli & Backroom Has Range Beyond Sandwiches
A playful daytime deli and nighttime hangout where breakfast burritos, fried chicken and an extensive sandwich menu drive the appeal.
More photos
Photos published by diners on Google, not AI generated.
What stands out
- Large sandwich selection
- Well-liked chicken dishes
- Frequently praised breakfast burritos
- Fun decor and atmosphere
- Daytime deli and nighttime backroom concept
Worth knowing
- Tuna may sell out
- One review found sandwich meat portions skimpy
Suggested meals
Dishes that come up most in public reviews
- Breakfast burrito
Worth a visit?
The public picture
Fillmore Deli & Backroom earns a 4.8 Google rating from 311 reviews, with diners repeatedly describing a neighborhood spot that offers more than its deli billing suggests. The defining feature is range. Public feedback points to a long sandwich menu, breakfast burritos, Korean fried chicken, chicken sandwiches and fries, all served in a space that shifts character from daytime deli to nighttime backroom hangout.
That variety appears to be central to the restaurant’s appeal. One reviewer counted four pages of sandwich choices, while another noted enough options to suit different cravings. It is not presented as a strictly Mexican restaurant, despite enthusiasm for the breakfast burritos, and it does not read as a conventional deli either. The result is an eclectic, casual menu rather than a tightly focused one.
What stands out
Chicken dishes receive some of the clearest praise. The Korean fried chicken is described as crisp and flavorful, while a separate diner singled out the chicken sandwich and fries. Breakfast burritos also surface more than once, earning a strong recommendation from one customer and anticipation from another planning a return visit.
Sandwich selection is the other major draw. Reviews mention a large number of combinations and visible toppings and options displayed on the wall. For diners who value choice, that breadth makes Fillmore useful for mixed groups or indecisive lunch plans. The menu seems designed to cover several moods rather than steer everyone toward one signature order.
Service comments are limited but positive. One review calls the people friendly, adding to the impression of an easygoing local stop rather than a polished destination restaurant.
Atmosphere and value
The room gets nearly as much attention as the food. Diners call the atmosphere cool and fun, with memorable items covering the walls. That decor gives the restaurant personality during the day, while the backroom or speakeasy-style identity adds another reason to consider it later on. Reviews suggest a social setting that could work well for bringing friends, not merely grabbing food and leaving.
The listed price level is budget friendly, though value may depend on the order. One diner thought the meat portion in a sandwich was skimpy for the price, even while saying the sandwich tasted good. That is the clearest reservation in an otherwise favorable set of comments.
Editorial take
Based on the supplied ratings and public reviews, Fillmore Deli & Backroom looks strongest as a flexible casual option: breakfast burrito in the morning, a broad sandwich choice later, or fried chicken with friends. Its identity is intentionally mixed, which may appeal more to diners seeking variety than to those wanting a traditional deli experience.
The main practical caution is availability. One regular complaint says the tuna often runs out, so anyone visiting specifically for that option may want a backup choice. Fortunately, the unusually broad menu should make switching orders relatively painless. Overall, the combination of well-liked chicken, recurring praise for breakfast burritos, abundant sandwiches and distinctive decor supports a confident recommendation.
Keep exploring near New York
More from NY
NY · New York · $$
All’Antico Vinaio Brings Big Italian Sandwiches to New York
Crisp, airy bread and generously filled sandwiches make this compact, mid-range counter spot a strong choice for sharing.
NY · New York · $
Joey Roses Makes a Strong Case for the Classic NYC Sub
Fresh bread, filling subs and warm bar service drive the enthusiastic public feedback for this budget-friendly Lower East Side sandwich shop.
NY · New York · $
Russ & Daughters remains a smoked-fish destination
The Lower East Side institution earns its reputation through excellent smoked salmon, broad cream cheese choices and classic bagel sandwiches.
NY · $
Defonte’s Sandwich Shop Serves Brooklyn-Scale Classics
Huge portions, seeded bread and old-school combinations make Defonte’s a dependable stop for filling, budget-friendly sandwiches.
Research-based review: our NY editor synthesized 311 public reviews and the current 4.8-star rating, not an anonymous visit.