Big Burgers and Crisp Fries at The Gettysburger Company

What the reviews say

The Gettysburger Company holds a 4.6 Google rating from 2318 reviews, and the supplied diner feedback gives its burgers most of the attention. Reviewers repeatedly describe the beef as fresh, thick, juicy and properly cooked. Toasted buns, crisp bacon and fresh toppings also earn praise, suggesting that the kitchen handles the supporting details well rather than relying on patty size alone.

These are not portrayed as restrained burgers. One diner called the Bully Burger gigantic, noting that it came with four smash patties, while another praised a substantial signature burger that still held together neatly in its bun. The Smokehouse Burger also received a positive mention. Taken together, the comments make this look like a strong candidate for diners seeking a filling American-style burger rather than a light lunch.

Fries, starters and family choices

Fries are the clearest recurring side recommendation. They appear as standard fries and as wedges or “pedal fries,” with reviewers calling them awesome and reporting that they were cooked properly. Jalapeño poppers and cheese curds were also well received in one account. The poppers were described as especially generous, reinforcing the broader pattern of large portions.

The menu appears workable for families as well. One review praised the children’s chicken fingers and grilled cheese alongside the adults’ burgers. That same account found the chicken particularly good rather than treating the kids’ food as an afterthought. Drinks and beer are also mentioned, making the restaurant suitable for a casual group meal where not everyone wants exactly the same thing.

Crab soup received a direct recommendation from one visitor. Because it appears less consistently than the burgers and fries in the supplied feedback, it is better viewed as an additional option than the restaurant’s defining order.

Service and atmosphere

Service comments are notably warm. Diners describe staff as attentive, polite and welcoming, and one first-time visitor said the team treated the family’s dog exceptionally well. That supports the restaurant’s appeal for travelers exploring Gettysburg with children or a pet, though anyone relying on pet-friendly seating should confirm the current policy and available area before arriving.

The overall mood sounds casual and upbeat, with a bar component that may continue operating after the kitchen stops taking food orders. One late-evening diner believed the kitchen was winding down around 9 p.m. but was not certain. Guests planning a later meal would be wise to verify kitchen hours rather than relying on the venue’s overall closing time.

Editorial verdict

Based on the public rating and review patterns provided, The Gettysburger Company is best approached as a mid-range, appetite-forward burger stop. Its strongest case rests on well-cooked beef, sturdy toasted buns, crisp fries and portions that satisfy. Friendly service adds to the appeal, particularly for families and visitors traveling with a dog.

The oversized builds may be more food than some diners want, and late-night kitchen availability appears worth checking. For most burger-focused visitors, however, the evidence points to a dependable, hearty meal with sides that deserve attention too.