The Brickyard Brings Burgers and Patio Energy to Williamsport

What the public ratings suggest

The Brickyard Restaurant & Ale House holds a 4.5 Google rating from more than 2,100 reviews, a strong level of approval for a busy bar and grill. Recent public feedback consistently emphasizes welcoming service, satisfying portions and familiar food handled well. Diners describe staff as kind and attentive, with prompt ordering and drink refills sometimes arriving without a request.

The overall picture is not of a restaurant chasing novelty. Instead, The Brickyard appears to succeed with approachable bar food, a lively setting and reliable execution. One reviewer specifically praised the combination of food, service and price, which supports its moderate price designation.

Burgers, fries and steak lead the menu feedback

Burgers receive some of the clearest praise. The Hangover Burger was described as juicy and flavorful, while another diner strongly recommended the Egg on Your Face burger. That repeated enthusiasm makes a burger the most evidence-backed starting point for a first meal.

Fries also earn attention across multiple reviews. They accompany the CBR, or chicken, bacon and ranch sandwich, in one positive account, while another reviewer calls them especially well seasoned. Diners looking for a straightforward bar-and-grill order should have good reason to pair the two.

Steak is another recurring strength. Separate reviewers report that it was cooked properly or to the requested level, including steak served with tacos. Burnt ends and the CBR sandwich also attracted enthusiastic individual mentions, although they appear less frequently in this limited review sample.

Not every dish lands equally well. One diner found the spinach and artichoke dip dull next to a particularly flavorful burger. The same review considered the brownie too sweet, even while praising its vanilla ice cream. Those are isolated criticisms rather than broad patterns, but they suggest the savory mains have a stronger public-review case than the appetizer or dessert selections.

An alley setting with appealing outdoor seating

The location appears to be part of the experience. Multiple diners enjoyed shaded outdoor seating, and one encountered live music shared across the alley. The atmosphere sounds well suited to a casual lunch, drinks with friends or an easy dinner when the weather cooperates. A hard cider on tap was another appreciated detail for one guest.

Finding the entrance may take a little attention. One reviewer said construction made the restaurant harder to locate and advised following directions into Pine Square and looking for the lit alleyway. That concern may be temporary, but first-time visitors should allow an extra minute rather than expecting a prominent roadside entrance.

The bottom line

Based on its large review count and repeated points of praise, The Brickyard looks like a dependable Williamsport choice for burgers, steak, fries and friendly service. Outdoor seating adds to the appeal, particularly when the alley has entertainment. The strongest order is likely a burger with fries, while diners focused on a larger entrée can take some confidence from the recurring reports of properly cooked steak.