Sickies Garage Brings Big Burger Energy to Fargo

Ratings and overall read

Sickies Garage Burgers & Brews holds a 4.5 Google rating from 4496 reviews, a substantial public response that points to enduring popularity in Fargo. The concept is easy to understand: specialty burgers, casual American food and a lively garage-themed dining room. It lands in the budget-friendly category and appears suited to families, groups and diners looking for a relaxed bar-and-grill atmosphere.

The available reviews do not tell a uniformly positive story, however. Enthusiastic diners praise juicy, flavorful burgers, personable employees and a fun setting. Less satisfied guests describe long waits, food arriving at disappointing temperatures and meals that did not match expectations. The overall picture is of a busy, high-energy restaurant that can deliver an enjoyable visit when the kitchen and service team are running smoothly.

Burgers lead the menu

Burgers are the clearest reason to consider Sickies Garage. Public feedback highlights the variety of specialty combinations, with the Sickies Burger and macaroni and cheese burger among the specifically mentioned choices. One family reported that its burgers were juicy and flavorful, while another diner found both named burgers disappointing.

That split is worth noting. The sauce on the Sickies Burger was described by one reviewer as strongly vinegar-forward, which may not suit diners sensitive to acidic flavors. The macaroni and cheese burger also drew criticism for falling short of its menu presentation. These are subjective reactions, but they suggest that the more elaborate builds can be divisive.

Milkshakes and desserts expand the family-friendly appeal. Mixed vegetables received a positive mention in an otherwise negative meal, while chicken served on salads was criticized as rubbery. Based on the review sample, the restaurant’s identity remains firmly centered on burgers rather than lighter plates.

Atmosphere and service

The setting earns some of the most consistent enthusiasm. Reviews call out the rusted truck, motorcycle, vintage fuel pumps and other garage-inspired decorations. That visual detail gives the dining room more personality than a standard sports bar and helps make it appealing for casual family outings.

Service experiences vary considerably. Several diners describe servers as friendly, nice or attentive. Others report missing silverware, waits exceeding 40 minutes and limited follow-up when problems arose. A Father’s Day visitor considered a delayed meal understandable because the restaurant was nearly full, suggesting that timing may deteriorate during major occasions and peak periods.

Takeaway ordering also carries some risk. One reviewer placed an order through the restaurant website, but the order did not reach the location despite the customer confirming the selected restaurant. Staff reportedly tried to investigate, yet the incident still points to a possible online-ordering breakdown.

Editorial verdict

Sickies Garage is best approached as an energetic burger stop rather than a precision-driven dining experience. Its strong aggregate rating, playful décor and wide burger focus make it a reasonable Fargo choice for families and casual groups. Friendly service appears common enough to be a genuine strength, but it is not guaranteed.

The principal concerns are consistency, especially during crowded periods. Long ticket times, room-temperature food and unreliable takeaway processing appear in the critical feedback. Diners prioritizing atmosphere and unconventional burgers may find plenty to enjoy, while those seeking fast, tightly consistent execution may want to visit outside the busiest hours.