Pazzo Italiano Delivers Standout Italian Takeout

The public verdict

Pazzo Italiano carries an unusually strong 4.8 Google rating from 367 reviews, and the supplied public feedback is remarkably consistent. Diners repeatedly praise the sandwiches, welcoming service, generous portions and quality of the Italian specialty goods. Several comments come from returning customers, including patrons who have ordered takeout on multiple occasions.

The shop previously operated as Frank and Loui’s, according to one reviewer, who felt the food and overall experience had improved under the current ownership and branding. That history may be useful for longtime Rehoboth Beach visitors, but the present appeal stands on its own: this is a budget-friendly Italian deli, bakery and food store with a strong carryout following.

Sandwiches lead the menu

Italian specialty sandwiches are the clearest reason to visit. Reviews describe thinly sliced meats piled generously onto crusty ciabatta, with fruity olive oil and spicy peppers providing extra character. The Sal’s Italian sub and C & C #2 receive specific recommendations, while another diner reports a satisfying, generously portioned meatball sub.

Across the comments, the pattern is more important than any single order. Sandwiches are repeatedly described as excellent or superb, with portions substantial enough to make lunch feel worthwhile. The selection appears rooted in familiar Italian deli combinations rather than elaborate restaurant plating, making Pazzo Italiano particularly well suited to a quick lunch, beach-day pickup or meal taken home.

More than a sandwich counter

The shelves and bakery case broaden the appeal. Public reviews mention cheeses, meats, pastries, pastas and other Italian staples, positioning the business as both a lunch stop and a place to stock up. Cannoli are described as fresh, while butter cakes, pizza bread and baked goods also earn recommendations.

Prepared takeout is another strength. One returning customer ordered ziti, followed the shop’s reheating instructions at home and found it plentiful and exceptionally good. That experience suggests Pazzo Italiano can cover more than an individual sandwich, particularly when a ready-to-heat meal is more practical than dining out.

Service and ordering

Friendly, fast customer service appears throughout the feedback. One out-of-state visitor made a call-ahead order a priority upon arriving in Delaware, while another reviewer directly recommends ordering by phone. For visitors with a tight schedule, calling ahead may be the most efficient approach.

The overall picture is of a family-run, takeout-focused Italian shop that earns loyalty through consistency rather than ceremony. Pazzo Italiano looks strongest for diners seeking hearty sandwiches, baked treats and Italian pantry items in one stop. With high marks for both food and hospitality, it ranks among Rehoboth Beach’s most promising casual lunch options.