GERE-a-DELI Sets a High Bar for Anacortes Sandwiches

The public verdict

GERE-a-DELI carries a 4.8 Google rating from 1122 reviews, a notably strong signal for a casual sandwich shop. Public feedback repeatedly centers on satisfying sandwiches, extensive choice and a friendly atmosphere. Several diners describe the deli as living up to its reputation, while another reports encountering a line out the door during the Anacortes Arts Festival.

This is a budget-friendly place built primarily for lunch, quick meals and takeaway, though reviews also note pleasant decor and seating for those who stay. Families, day-trippers and diners looking for a straightforward deli meal all appear well served by the format.

Sandwiches lead the menu

The Reuben receives the most repeated attention, though experiences differ. One reviewer calls it among the best versions they have tried, while another says a half Reuben was light on meat. That contrast suggests the sandwich is a leading order, but portion consistency may not satisfy everyone.

Other named sandwiches draw enthusiastic responses. The Gobbler is described as excellent. A French dip earns praise for thick-sliced, tender roast beef and quality bread, although its au jus struck one diner as milder than preferred. The hot pastrami on rye also receives unusually strong approval from a well-traveled reviewer.

Beyond individual orders, the breadth of the sandwich menu is a recurring advantage. One family noted that many options sounded appealing enough to require several return visits. For a first meal, the Reuben remains the clearest consensus choice because it appears across multiple reviews.

Service and surroundings

The service pattern is encouraging. A visitor asking for recommendations found the staff genuinely kind and helpful, and another review pairs wonderful service with an enjoyable atmosphere. Comments about nice decor and seating support the sense that GERE-a-DELI works as more than a grab-and-go counter, even with takeaway among its practical strengths.

The strong rating also aligns with the repeated language of satisfaction in the sample feedback. Reviewers mention reasonable prices, good family lunches and a welcoming environment. Taken together, those comments position the deli as an accessible, low-pressure option rather than a special-occasion restaurant.

What to weigh before ordering

The sandwiches generate the clearest praise, while the soups appear less dependable. One diner tried both split pea and ham and tomato bisque, found neither thick nor creamy, and would not order them again. That same review praised the coleslaw, reinforcing the case for choosing a cold side rather than assuming soup is the best accompaniment.

Facilities may also lag behind the dining room experience. One customer specifically said the bathroom needed renovation. Lines can be another consideration during major local events. Overall, however, the public record points to a highly regarded, budget-friendly deli where the long sandwich list, personable staff and relaxed setting outweigh the relatively limited criticisms.