Five Islands Lobster Co: Seafood With a Harbor View

The public-review picture

Five Islands Lobster Co earns a 4.7 Google rating from 1330 reviews, and the supplied feedback presents a remarkably consistent picture. Diners praise the seafood, harbor views and easygoing atmosphere, often describing the restaurant as a place worth revisiting whenever they return to Georgetown. One reviewer ate there three times during a single week, while another returned after a long absence and immediately resolved not to wait so long again.

This assessment is synthesized from public ratings and the review sample rather than an in-person visit. Within that feedback, the strongest recurring themes are freshness, friendly interactions and the appeal of eating seafood beside the water. The experience sounds casual and unpolished in the best sense, with the setting carrying as much weight as the menu.

Setting and atmosphere

The outdoor deck is central to the appeal. Reviews describe broad harbor views, a rocky shoreline and an atmosphere that remains striking even on a foggy day. The scenery appears to suit diners looking for a classic Maine coast experience rather than a formal dining room.

Weather matters. One reviewer found the deck hot but noted a shady eating area behind the ice cream shack. Seagulls are another practical consideration, particularly around French fries. That detail reinforces the open-air, working-harbor character, though diners will want to keep a close eye on their food.

The ordering arrangement may take a moment to understand. One review mentions ordering from the snack bar before noticing that a full lobster and clam meal was available from the neighboring red shed. Diners focused on a traditional lobster dinner may want to look over both options before choosing a line.

What diners recommend

Lobster is the obvious draw, appearing across several reviews in different forms. Lobster rolls were described as fresh and delicious, while another diner planned to return for the full lobster and clam meal. A more elaborate option, the Jenny Special, was praised for combining grilled haddock, a crab cake, fresh corn and soft-shell lobsters.

The menu’s supporting cast also receives encouraging feedback. Steamed clams, onion rings, hot dogs and ice cream all earned positive mentions from a repeat visitor. Fried oysters drew especially detailed praise for a crisp exterior and tender, briny center. These individual reports do not establish that every dish performs equally, but they suggest that the kitchen’s strengths extend beyond lobster alone.

Before making the trip

Five Islands Lobster Co appears best suited to diners who value setting, seafood and informality over polished service rituals. Its mid range price positioning matches the casual counter-service impression conveyed by the reviews, while the waterfront location gives the meal a stronger sense of occasion.

The clearest verdict from the public feedback is that this is as much a destination for atmosphere as for lunch or dinner. Repeat visits, consistently enthusiastic food comments and the 4.7 rating all support its standing as a strong Georgetown seafood stop. The main cautions are practical rather than culinary: sun exposure, opportunistic gulls and an ordering setup that may not be immediately obvious.