Brick St. Deli & Notion Makes the Smoke Show the Main Event

What public feedback says

Brick St. Deli & Notion holds a 4.8 Google rating from 132 reviews, with the available feedback repeatedly praising flavorful sandwiches and friendly service. Diners describe a warm welcome, helpful menu guidance and an operation that feels organized enough for a quick lunch without losing its personable character. One first-time guest appreciated having the menu explained, while another credited a front-of-house recommendation for steering them toward a memorable sandwich.

The mood also earns favorable mentions. A dinner visitor called the atmosphere fun, relaxed and upbeat. That combination suggests a deli that works for an uncomplicated midday meal but does not feel restricted to grab-and-go traffic. Its location on North Buckeye Street, near downtown Kokomo, also makes it a practical stop for people already in the area.

The sandwich to order

The Smoke Show is the clearest consensus choice in these reviews. It appears repeatedly, including accounts from a local couple, a visitor traveling between Indianapolis and Kokomo, and diners who stopped in for lunch. Reviewers describe smoked turkey, bacon jam, fresh meat and toppings, and satisfying bread. The bacon jam is the detail most likely to distinguish it from a standard turkey sandwich, adding a sweet-savory element that left several diners especially enthusiastic.

The Reuben also received a positive report, although the diner who tried both sandwiches preferred the Smoke Show. Based strictly on the recurring review pattern, newcomers have the strongest reason to start with the latter. The comments also indicate that sharing may be possible for some diners, as one couple split a Smoke Show at dinner, though appetite and portion preferences will vary.

Sides, options and drinks

Side dishes receive less attention than the sandwiches, but the mentions are encouraging. Crab salad and pasta salad were both described favorably in one lunch review, while another diner specifically enjoyed the Green Goddess slaw. These sides provide alternatives to treating the sandwich as a standalone order.

One repeat visitor reported that gluten-free bread was available, which may broaden the deli’s appeal for some guests. That detail should still be confirmed directly when dietary needs or cross-contact concerns matter. A first-time diner was also pleasantly surprised to find beer, including a peanut butter stout that caught their interest for a future visit. The reviews provided do not offer enough detail to characterize the broader drink list.

Value and overall take

Listing data places Brick St. Deli & Notion in the budget-friendly category, though one reviewer considered it a little pricey and still felt the experience was worthwhile. That mild tension suggests value may depend on expectations for a deli sandwich, particularly when premium fillings and distinctive toppings are involved.

Taken together, public ratings and diner comments point to a strong downtown Kokomo sandwich shop with attentive service and one especially reliable signature order. The Smoke Show dominates the feedback, but positive notes on the Reuben, salads, gluten-free bread and relaxed atmosphere give the restaurant appeal beyond a single item. For a first visit, the safest plan is straightforward: order the Smoke Show, add a reviewed side and see why it keeps driving the conversation.