Anthony’s at the Old Mill District: Seafood With a View

What the public feedback suggests

Anthony’s at the Old Mill District presents itself as a polished seafood restaurant where the setting matters nearly as much as the plate. Based on its Google rating of 4.3 from 1475 reviews and the supplied diner feedback, the clearest strengths are river views, a comfortable dining room and a menu that leans into Northwest seafood.

Several reviews describe an attractive space with large windows overlooking the water. One diner noted that the windows created an open-air feeling while still providing shelter from rain and cold. Outdoor seating adds another option when the weather cooperates, though it may be less appealing during extreme heat. Inside, the noise level appears suitable for conversation rather than overpowering.

Seafood leads the menu

The reviewed dishes cover a broad seafood range. Hawaiian Ahi Nachos and Wild Alaska Black Cod earned praise for their flavors, while crab cakes were described enthusiastically. Lobster made an especially strong impression on one diner, and another table recommended the rockfish taco to friends who also enjoyed it. These reports suggest a menu that works for both a full seafood dinner and a more casual taco or appetizer order.

Not every preparation lands equally well for every guest. One returning diner did not enjoy the lingcod with pilaf, although the review framed that response as a matter of personal taste. That same guest praised the bread, even while describing the visit overall as disappointing. The pattern points to seafood as the main reason to book, but diners who are particular about fish preparations may want to ask questions before ordering.

Service and special occasions

Service receives repeated approval. Diners mention attentive, professional care and well-paced meals, including an anniversary visit marked by a card and a complimentary heart-shaped piece of cake. That kind of recognition helps explain why some customers return for annual celebrations.

The restaurant also appears well suited to date nights and meals with friends. Comfortable sound levels support conversation, drinks such as mojitos and wine have been positively mentioned, and the combination of water views and seafood gives the room a sense of occasion without requiring an ultra-formal experience. Pricing is best described as mid range.

Where expectations should be managed

Consistency is the main concern in the supplied reviews. One repeat customer reported a slower start to the meal, delayed bread and dirty, sticky salt and pepper containers. Staff replaced the containers willingly, but the lapse still stands out against the otherwise positive service reports.

Overall, Anthony’s looks most dependable when chosen for its river-facing atmosphere, seafood selection and celebration-friendly service. The large windows offer a practical advantage in poor weather, while the patio broadens its appeal on comfortable days. Diners should leave room for dessert, which receives positive attention alongside the seafood.