Agave Mexican Grill brings a strong fajita game to Florence

What public feedback says

Agave Mexican Grill holds a 4.7 Google rating from 208 reviews, and the available feedback points to a restaurant that earns repeat business through flavorful food and notably attentive service. Several diners describe it as a favorite among Mexican restaurants in Florence and the wider Shoals area. That level of praise is subjective, but the pattern is clear: customers often leave pleased enough to return and recommend it.

The restaurant occupies what one reviewer identified as a former bank building. Its dining room also receives direct praise for attractive decoration, giving the setting more personality than a purely functional neighborhood stop. Combined with a budget-friendly menu, that makes Agave suitable for both an easy lunch and a relaxed family dinner.

What to order

Fajita-based dishes stand out most consistently in the sample reviews. One returning customer names the fajita bowl as a favorite, while another reports a successful steak and chicken fajita order. Fajita enchiladas topped with cheese and pico also receive enthusiastic approval. Those mentions suggest that diners interested in grilled meats, vegetables and familiar Tex-Mex combinations have several promising ways to order.

The Hawaiian Chicken and lunch combo plate are also praised in one group meal, showing some range beyond the recurring fajita theme. Still, the public comments supplied here make fajitas the clearest starting point. The varied formats, from a bowl to enchiladas, also give regulars room to change up an order without leaving that core flavor profile.

Service and atmosphere

Service is one of Agave’s strongest recurring advantages. Reviews describe staff members as friendly, accommodating and attentive. One parent dining with five children particularly praised the team for keeping drinks filled, responding patiently to accidental spills and maintaining a welcoming attitude throughout the meal. Another diner singled out the manager as kind and friendly.

That feedback makes Agave look especially useful for families and groups, where steady drink refills and patient service can matter as much as the food. The decorated dining room adds to the appeal for those eating in, while the affordable menu keeps the restaurant within budget-friendly territory.

What to watch for

The main caution comes from a Sunday takeout experience. That reviewer still considered the food genuinely delicious, but reported receiving a cold steak smothered burrito and an order missing fajita vegetables despite arriving before the scheduled pickup time. It is a single account rather than a broad pattern, yet it suggests that execution can slip during a busy weekend rush.

Dining in appears to be the safer bet based on this review sample, particularly for customers who want the attentive service others praise. Overall, Agave Mexican Grill pairs strong public sentiment with appealing fajita dishes, a polished dining room and family-friendly hospitality. The occasional takeout issue is worth noting, but it does not outweigh the consistently positive themes in the available feedback.